A breach at IRINN systems could have affected India’s over 6000 ISPs, Government and Private Organisations.
We at Seqrite’s Cyber Intelligence Labs (https://seqrite.com) working closely with our Partner, seQtree InfoServices (https://seqtree.com/) recently tracked a broadcast advertisement on a Darknet platform where an underground actor had advertised access to the servers and database dump of an unspecified Internet Registry. Following a detailed research the team identified the affected organization as India’s National Internet Registry: IRINN (Indian Registry for Internet Names and Numbers) which comes under NIXI (National Internet Exchange of India). The sample screenshots (shared by actor) confirmed that compromise was real.
As per the standard protocol, we have contacted the appropriate agencies and sensitized them about the possible breach at IRINN.
Here is the detailed sequence of events related to this compromise:
- Upon noticing the broadcast advertisement, seQtree and Seqrite teams started gathering background research on the actor but did not yield any concrete information.
- But the team didn’t get any relevant data even after conducting deep research and it appeared that this actor’s persona was created recently. This is an ongoing trend that the team has noticed with recent data breaches.
- The team then contacted the actor for further details, posing as an interested buyer. Initially the actor was not willing to disclose the name of affected Internet Registry, however, later he agreed to share a small sample of email list from the allegedly compromised database.
- In the sample, the team noticed email address of a prominent Indian technology firm and another email address was from Indian government. Then the team asked for complete/extensive emails list.
- Eventually, the actor agreed to share a text file containing the emails of users/organizations affected, allegedly from the compromised database(s). The text file contained a list of approx. 6000 emails.
- It was observed some of the most important and high-profile organizations featured in the list. At this point, the team first thought the possibility of the affected organization being India’s National Internet Registry: IRINN (Indian Registry for Internet Names and Numbers) which comes under NIXI.
- To confirm our suspicion, we probed the actor further. The actor agreed to share screenshots which confirmed our suspicion that the compromise/breach is, unfortunately true and IRINN is the affected organization.
- The actor also hinted on the chat that if he doesn’t find any interested buyer, actor will consider posting this on Darknet forum(s)/marketplace(s).
- If he gets an interested buyer, then attack on the system could have disrupted Internet IP allocation and in-turn the complete Internet in India.
This can be a major tool of mass disruption if a state actor gets hands on it.
Below is the list of selective few organizations whose services could have been disrupted and also the sample screenshots to confirm our observation.
Indian Government | Telecom/ ISPs | Financial Organisations | Technology Firms |
UIDAI (Aadhaar) | Idea Telecom | Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) | Flipkart
|
DRDO | Aircel | Mastercard / Visa | Ernst & Young (E&Y) |
Reserve Bank of India | BSNL | SBI | TCS |
ISRO | You Broadband | HDFC | Wipro |
ISRO Satellite Centre (ISAC) | Spectranet | ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund | VMWare |
Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation | Hathway | BNY Mellon | eClerx |
Various Indian state government portals (e.g. Maharashtra Online, MP Online) | Sify | IDBI Bank | Zoho |
Vikram Sarabhai Space Centre | Tikona | Federal Bank | |
National Centre for Antarctic and Ocean Research | Royal Bank of Scotland | ||
Edelweiss Tokio | |||
Dena Bank | |||
IDFC Bank | |||
Canara Bank |
Screenshots
Some of the censored screenshots (we have blurred the personal details) are attached below,
Fig. (1)
Fig. (2)
Fig. (3)
Assessment
We assessed the following from our research and the shared screenshots:
- The actor has a database related to IRINN, as well as some database related to APNIC (“apnicdb” in screenshot 1).
- The price set by actor for the database was/is 15BTC (approx. 61500USD in present rate).
- The actor can access other’s portal on IRINN website. This might indicate that along with email addresses, the actor also has access to passwords (as visible in screenshot 2 and 3).
- The actor can possibly control IP/ASN allocation/de-allocation for various organizations (as visible in screenshot 2).
- Actor might have access to internal sensitive documents uploaded by IRINN users (a PDF file is visible in screenshot 3).
Further Update as on 28th September 2017:
Our team noticed a post in Darknet forum, which provides clear indication that actor has started advertising about availability of this information on public Darknet forums as well. Screenshots are below:
Fig. (4)
Fig. (5)
In the above screenshots, we can see that the actor is asking for 15 BTC in exchange of the IRINN’s database.
Implications
Assessing from the screenshot and emails list shared with our team, we believe this compromise could have serious implications for the affected organizations.
The forum post suggests that the actor has the Username, Passwords, Emails, Organization names, Invoices and Billing documents, etc. among other documents.
If an actor gets access to any organization’s IRINN portal, they might be able to de-allocate/delete IP/ASN, therefore, causing outage and Denial-of-service for the users and organizations.
Actions
We have notified appropriate agencies in the Government and have got an acknowledgement that the issue has been taken care of.
Hopefully this will not lead to any disruption. Proactive monitoring and reporting in any such case can always avert major damages.
All Intellectual Property Right(s) including trademark(s), logo(s) and copyright(s) are properties of their respective owners. Copyright © 2017 Quick Heal Technologies Ltd. All rights reserved.
Hey Team,
Which forum did you get this broadcast on ? Can you send the details on the mail id ?
NIXI’s reply :
It has come to our knowledge that a business organization dealing with enterprise security solution has sent information to various news agencies that it has found that an advertisement was given on darknet announcing secret access to data bases of over 6000 business and ISPs, Government and private organization and the said actor is attempting to sell this database of Indian Registry for Internet Names and Numbers (IRINN). It claimed that seller’s ability to temper the IP allocation pool will cause huge outage or distributed denial of service. It also mentioned the names of several prominent private and Government entities were displayed by the actor.
NIXI hereby clarifies that there has been no serious security breach of its IRINN system, as it has a robust security protocol in place. The hacker has no capacity to cause any damage or initiate distributed denial of service to any entity who has been allocated Internet resources through IRINN System. There was an attempt to penetrate the system and hacker was able to collect some basic profile information of the contact persons of some of the affiliates which was displayed by him on the darknet. The existing security protocol of NIXI is robust and capable in countering such attacks. However, following this breach, security protocol has been further strengthened and review of existing infrastructure has also been initiated.
We assure our affiliates and all concerned that our system is secured and security protocol in practice is capable of handling such attacks. The claim by the actor of Dark Net is audacious and far from truth.
This for information of all the concerned.
Dear Rohit,
Could you kindly explain more regarding the impact it could cause specifically to financial/banking sector.
Abhisht
Hello Sir,
Whether we talk about enterprise or system architecture, their safety must be a primary requirement.
The system must be designed with integrated security rather than it being added as a patch later. While building the system, safe coding practices must be followed and security must be built into the business processes.
A separate role for information security officer must be created to take charge of cyber security of the organization.
Adding security aspects after the enterprise architecture or system is designed and implemented, will make the security solution complex.
It seems that there can never be a time when a perfect, impenetrable system will be created and deployed for long before a vulnerable node is spotted by hackers.
However, there are certain measures that organizations can take to protect and secure the fragile network, data and resources which form the backbone of operations in this age of information.
Hi,
Your article last 2 para is confusing. One side you talk about the data affected and its implication and other you say you communicated to the concerned. If the database is compromised already, how can you protect by communicating. When it is up for sale is a finished case but not a prevention. You have evidence that IRNN has been compromised but not mitigated. Need clarity for the title of the article since it circulates a lot.
How can a common Individual of India stay online safely when Whole Internet directory of India is not safe.
Something unusual happening in the NIXI (for .in and .bharat domain registration data). Info can be found at [https://www.namepros.com/threads/termination-of-domain-registrar-mitsu-inc-by-nixi.1047610/]. Whois data for domains registered in Mitsu.in is now changed. Sponsoring registrar now showing as “NIXI Holding Account (R189-AFIN)” instead of “Business Solutions (R54-AFIN)”. Domain data changed between (for my domains) 24th October to 27th October.